WHAT WILL MAKE US TRULY PROUD OF OURSELVES?
Dorothy Koppelman



Continued: Part C

  Home Aesthetic Realism Foundation

Home Terrain Gallery

Aesthetic Realism Online Library
  Aesthetic Realism in the Press International Periodical Contact
HUMANITY IS HIGH AND LOW:
AESTHETIC OPPOSITES, ETHICAL OPPOSITES
I have learned from Aesthetic Realism that a painting solves in outline, the questions of our lives, including of the artist himself. When we see height and lawns made one in a painting, when we look up and down for the same purpose, humility and pride are closer in us too. Every artist is dealing with these opposites in himself as he paints. In the court of Spain Velázquez felt he was both "ennobled" and in "bondage" as the Metropolitan Museum catalogue puts it. He had the high esteem and affection of the king but in order to have economic security for himself and his family the artist had to be employed as "Gentleman of the Bedchamber," and later as "Palace Chamberlain." He arranged for the construction of buildings, he hired the carpenters; he served as the king's ambassador all over Italy choosing and buying works of art for the Palace. Meanwhile in 17th century Spain being an artist was a "low and base calling." On the one hand, he was the king's preferred painter—and famous—on the other hand he was given duties "onerous, burdensome, time-consuming." 

Velázquez felt justly that his true pride came from his way of seeing, and he wanted the profession of painting to be lifted from its low status. At the same time, he was intent on being admitted to an order of Knighthood, and spent many years trying to obtain documents proving that his Portuguese father was of noble birth with no taint of "impure blood." 

It is likely that his tiredness as time went on came from an unseen conflict in him about where his vanity might take him and where his true pride was. In "Art As, Yes, Humility," Eli Siegel writes: 

The self gets in the way of humility; and artists have had to learn how to stop the tendency of the narrow, limited, fearful, monarchic self to interfere with pure, rich, just seeing.The only criticism in the world which understands the harm and can oppose the "narrow, limited, fearful monarchic self" is that taught by the Aesthetic Realism of Eli Siegel: the aesthetic criticism of self.

"THE EMBODIMENT OF SUCCESSFUL HUMILITY"

"Art," writes Eli Siegel, "can be regarded as the embodiment of the successful humility of a person before the shows of existence, before existence itself....Art, itself, is humility at one with pride." That is the way of seeing Eli Siegel had all the time; it is the only opposition to what Mr. Siegel described as the "inner sneer" which I once had and which hurts people so terribly. 

One of the greatest triumphs of art—and it was the triumph of Velázquez—is the finding of beauty in the ill-formed, the misshapen, the ugly. In the 17th century court of Spain, dwarfs and buffoons were pitied, taken care of, and served as jesters to lighten the burdens of the monarchs. Velázquez, however, looked at the dwarfs for a different purpose; he saw the opposites of reality.


Sebastian de Morra
[click here for full screen picture]
Here is Sebastian de Morra. We see a broad, light brow and eyes that in their depth make one almost cry with love. See how the arms, with their light and sturdy fists press down?—the little legs come towards us and the light slippered feet point upwards with their tops glowing softly? Those feet, with their curved motion, and vertical direction make us feel a standing person. The kindness of art is that we cannot look down on Sebastian de Morra without looking up. 

The dwarf is in the center of the canvas. His dark green coat is divided up and down the middle, and just where his fists press down there is another division right across the center. We find perfect geometry in that imperfect body. Let your eyes travel around the shape of the whole man. It is a circle, the most complete, continuous, non-stunted shape in the world. Coming out of that circle is the warmth of the whole self of Sebastian de Morra in his light pink and gold cape, with his ever so slightly tilted, questioning head, his wise mouth and those deep brown eyes. This is man as noble, and as Eli Siegel wrote "alive: / And so at times, grotesque." The purpose of Aesthetic Realism consultations is to teach persons how to see the relation of opposites—the dark and light, the complete and incomplete, high and low, good and evil, in the world and in ourselves. Every painting by Velázquez celebrates that purpose. 

In 1656, four years before he died, Velázquez painted the work—to quote Eli Siegel's poem—in which, "A thing reflected mingles with the here, / The seen...." 


The Maids of Honor
[click here for full screen picture]
The heiress to the throne of Spain is the center of The Maids of Honor but the artist is studying persons high and low as they bow, entreat, kneel and stand by. The large face of the dwarf on the right is so near the imperious little princess. The symmetry of space and rectangle in that dark room has a serene nobility that includes the bumping irregularities of the nobles and servants in the foreground. Velázquez has put together the opposites of all time in the great space of that room; the light that enters as the courtier lifts the curtain becomes warm as it touches the artist's canvas. 

And there is Velázquez himself, looking at the royal couple perhaps, reflected in the distant mirror, and he is looking at us.

Velázquez and his paintings say Yes over the centuries to the most beautiful message in the world: that of Aesthetic Realism, true about the world, true about art, true about every self—it is in these lines of Eli Siegel's "Free Poem on 'The Siegel Theory of Opposites' in Relation to Aesthetics" with which I end my paper: 
The opposites are surely elsewhere, too, 
In more, more ways, my friends, in more, more things. 
Ah, let us see them where they are—because 
They make OURSELVES, they make the WORLD, that which 
In honesty, we like; in pride, we are.

Back to Part B ... Click here
Back to Part A ... Click here

  Home Aesthetic Realism Foundation

Home Terrain Gallery

Aesthetic Realism Online Library
  Aesthetic Realism in the Press International Periodical Contact

Copyright 2000-6 by Aesthetic Realism Foundation, a not-for-profit educational foundation